I have to pump gas to start

I want to see if we can narrow this down. My hypothisis is that the fuel is draining back into the tank after setting. Essentially pumping the accelerator on a fuel injected engine should only give the ankle a workout. I "think" if your were to continue cranking it would start regardless. Maybe I'm wrong, but let's try this:
When go to start the car in the morning, cycle the key. That is turn the key to the run position without cranking for 3 seconds, turn it back to the off position for a few seconds. Do this 3-4 times. Then crank it, does it start?

Were you smelling raw fuel at any other point?

If not I would be highly suspicious of a bad fuel pump.

Well what I meant was that there may be a fuel leak happening. When it sets, the fuel may be draining out of the line. If not, then back into the tank, but then I wouldn't expect and smell.

I would get it on a lift, cycle the key and look for a potential problem. Also I would check the fuel pressure, when the problem is expected to happen and see what it is and see how long it takes to lose pressure.

So I wouldn't say that there may be a problem other thant the pump, but odds are stacked in fovor of it.