I decided to go for the master cylinder for the following reasons.
1/ ABS warning light never comes on.
2/ ABS should fail, if failed, in a "safe" mode, such that it would be removed from the normal brake system. It should never fail in a "locked wheel" mode. That would be big time liability.
3/ MC is easier to change. ABS requires the MC to be remove anyway.
4/ MC is a lot cheaper in parts cost (BTW, AutoZone gave me a wrong part, their database list a wrong part. One of the two hydraulic port use a different type flair on the steel line)
5/ The MC suppose to have free flow upstream and it was not doing that. THIS is the direct evidence pointing to the MC.
6/ "Evidence" pointing to the ABS modulator is not directly observable. Only in a questing of why only one wheel is locked.
The answer. After $200 for a new MC from Nissan.
FIXED !
Mistakes along the way.
1/ I jump the gun in replacing the caliper, that was not it. Should have done a better job in the problem analysis. You know how it is. No spare car, everything have to be zip up by sunday night! I figured, 3 hours job.
2/ A friend had a lock up wheel and it turned out to be a rubber brake hose. By this time, I had already diagnosed this to be the MC. I figured a hose is easy to replace and only $20. Low price to pay. Little did I know that it'll cost me a whole day trying to get the flare nut loose and the mangled flair nut back on and maintained a good seal!
Sunday, March 30th, 2008 AT 4:04 PM