2003 Ford F-150



August, 27, 2008 AT 11:40 AM

Smells problem
2003 Ford F150 V8 Two Wheel Drive Automatic 120K miles

A few days ago and after driving through 1' of water puddle, my truck (2003, F-150/4.6) started to run rough - also have a rotten egg smell. For the most part, truck runs good at idle but gets worse when I accelerate. When I accelerate, the engine seems to " bogg-down" but eventually catches-on and smooths out. This also happened a few months ago (but without the egg smell) after a fuel fill-up and I thought I bought bad gas. At that time, I added a higher octane fuel and also changed the fuel filter (filter was not clogged and no water). Within a day, my truck ran great. I don't recall driving through water at that time. No check engine light has come on in either case.


Running Rough


Idles Rough/changed Ects


3 Answers



August, 27, 2008 AT 11:55 PM

Sounds like the Catalytic Converter has failed due to the following below

Unburned fuel may be getting into the exhaust because of a bad spark plug or valve, but an overly rich air/fuel mixture is another possibility. In older carbureted engines, a heavy or misadjusted carburetor float may be the underlying cause. But on newer engines with " feedback" carburetion or electronic fuel injection, the engine may not be going into " closed loop" (the normal mode where the computer regulates the air/fuel mixture to minimize emissions).

A bad oxygen sensor or coolant sensor may be giving the computer bogus information. A sluggish or dead O2 sensor will make the computer think the exhaust is running lean, so the computer will try to compensate by making the fuel mixture rich. A coolant sensor that always indicates a cold engine will also keep the system in open loop, which means a steady diet of excess fuel. But it might not be the sensor's fault. A thermostat that's stuck open or is too cold for the application can prevent the engine from reaching its normal operating temperature. So if your converter has failed and needs to be replaced, the engine should be diagnosed for any underlying problems before the new converter is installed.

Another cause of converter clogging and contamination is excessive oil consumption. Worn valve guides or seals can allow oil to be sucked into the engine's combustion chambers. The same goes for worn or damaged rings or cylinders. Oil can form a great deal of carbon, and metals present in the oil can contaminate the catalyst. A compression check or leak-down test will tell you if the rings are leaking, while a fluttering vacuum gauge needle will help you identify worn valve guides



August, 28, 2008 AT 4:43 AM

Thanks for the reply.
Fuel mileage is really good and the engine doesn't burn any oil. Basically, the engine is in great condition with the exception of this problem. I thought about the O2 Sensor and the Cat. But wasn't sure because after the first incident occurred, the engine corrected itself and ran great for a few months. Is it possible for the O2 sensor or Cat to be bad then correct itself and go bad again? I might just be better off by just getting it on a diagnostic machine?



August, 28, 2008 AT 5:43 AM

The best direction to take is to put it on a 5 gas analysis machine this will tell what's going between the snitcher ( oxygen sensor ) and the converter ( scrubber ) or a vacuum check and exhaust backpressure test.

Viewing the live data on a scantool-

Please login or register to post a reply.

Code Read Retrieval/Clear Chevrolet Camaro
Code Read Retrieval/Clear Mercedes-Benz C230
Read Codes Like a Pro
Code Read Retrieval/Clear
 Step by Step video GMC Yukon XL 2000-2006
Code Read Retrieval/Clear Honda Civic
Code Read Retrieval/Clear Scion XD