Brake bleeding problems?

Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Yeah I don't know if you bench blood it or not or just put it on and then tried to bleed the brakes. But he said they had it bleeding with the other one on and they had to replace a brake caliper that the threads were leaking somewhere. You didn't specify what hose or where it was leaking but he said the threads were bad on one of the brand new calipers. And then when they put the new caliper on it started bleeding as it did before with the left front and the right rear and not the right front driver's rear wasn't bleeding. I don't know how that is possible I guess if it was bleeding before they put the new caliper on so after that they had me order the new master cylinder again so this is the second master cylinder that I bought and they installed and now they said it's the same thing that they are only getting it to come out of the two wheels. I am going to probably have to buy another master cylinder cuz I really don't have the time with my schedule at work to go haul the car myself with our truck and trailer from our shop during the week because I can't get the time off to do it myself but I would like to just pay them and then get the car to someone else that knows what they're doing and I'd like to let them know that before I get my bill because I have a feeling they will skyrocket my bill up if I take it somewhere else. But I really don't want to pay the labor for them to install another master cylinder just for that not to work again. Or I should tell them if I do buy a new master cylinder and if it does not work I am not going to pay for the labor for them putting that one on again
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, August 16th, 2025 AT 9:05 AM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
I just wish this mechanic, if he cannot figure it out just tell me he does not know what it is and quit trying to guess what it is because I live on a paycheck to paycheck type of wage and I can't afford trial and error on this car and I need this car for the gas mileage because I cannot afford driving what I'm driving right now at all, as we have reduced our hours because of the heat during the week for work
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, August 16th, 2025 AT 9:07 AM
Tiny
KEN L
  • MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
  • 54,137 POSTS
I would just get it out of there and tell the story to another shop, obviously the current machinic cannot do the job. Sorry.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, August 16th, 2025 AT 7:23 PM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Ok thats the plan anyways. Thanks for all of your time and help. It is much appreciated! Hope you had a good weekend
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, August 16th, 2025 AT 11:40 PM
Tiny
KEN L
  • MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
  • 54,137 POSTS
You are welcome, please let me know what happens to the car once repaired :)
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Sunday, August 17th, 2025 AT 12:01 PM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
I will definitely let you know. Right now I'm waiting for the bill to see what the damage is going to be for what they didn't fix LOL. But I should be able to get it out hopefully this Friday if it is not too much. We have been cut hours because of the heat for work so I'm hoping my paycheck will be big enough to get it out of the shop. I'm almost scared that I'm not going to be making enough hours to be able to pay for it to get it out of there for the next couple weeks and hopefully he does not tow it or something or sell it or whatever they do if the car sits too long. But I had another question I just remembered one of the break lines coming off of the ABS block. I had to replace and it's not the same size it's a standard but we took the nut off of the old one and reflared the new line to make it fit on with that nut. Would that have anything to do with the pressure of the Pistons inside it making them stick and not bleeding? Even if my abs wasn't working? Just curious that was something I totally forgot that happened and that I did also I did measure the metric and standard to see what standard converts over to metric and I got it as close as I could I cannot remember for sure the size right now right off hand it's been so long ago when I did that. But I didn't know if the pressure in the lines would have something to do with them not bleeding properly as well? Again thanks for all of your time in reading all these I know you're probably pretty busy with a bunch of other people on forums as well. I have a buddy that does customer support tech for factory machinery and stuff like where they process hogs and such. So I know kind of what you do for work. And that's pretty cool hopefully you get to stay at home and work from home as well as my buddy does but he does have to go out and fix some stuff if they cannot figure it out sometimes LOL
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, August 19th, 2025 AT 9:35 PM
Tiny
KEN L
  • MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
  • 54,137 POSTS
No worries, I am glad to help, as long as the brake line is not leaking you should be okay. Also, you can use vise grips to gently close off the brake flex hoses to help see if the problem is in the master or wheels, please go over this guide again.

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/brake-pedal-goes-to-the-floor

Please go over this guide and get back to us.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Wednesday, August 20th, 2025 AT 9:55 AM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Okay so an update on my car I get it out of the shop $60 later. Nothing is fixed on it except for pretty much the brake hose that I wore a hole through and it was leaking so now it holds pressure into brakes again the same as when I was driving it before I took it to the shop. They did not repair the rear brake caliper and install my new rotor and pads that I had for them to install instead they changed the two front rotors which have already had brand new ones on it and the one was never blood or working so it has never been used I don't know why they would replace it and then they return them for a core charge as well and didn't even give me the brakes back that I paid for and that were brand new on the vehicle another thing they were supposed to change the pads in the rotor on the driver's front which they did not do because the parts are still sitting in my backseat all the parts I gave them are still in my car that I wanted them to replace and then they had me by two Master cylinders and wanted me to buy a third while I got one master cylinder back that I bought and I want the original one and they don't think they have that either.

That really screwed me over and didn't even fix my car and now the alternator just went out of it when I got it back the same day. So I don't know if they had something to do with that as well but I would not recommend Benton Auto in fort Dodge Iowa to anyone because the guy is a freaking idiot. I would call to try to get updates and stuff during the week and never got any call backs I would either have to stop at the shop or just keep calling until I finally got him off guard I think. I don't know if there's anything I can do or anyone I can go to to deal with this I could take him to court but it probably wouldn't even be worth it because there is no estimate saying what you was supposed to do with the car at first when I dropped it off.

But I do have the receipts for all the new parts that he was supposed to install I never did and I still have the parts in my backseat. He had my car for two and a half months to install some brake parts and bleed the brakes. I am really not happy about the whole deal I would like to punch the guy right in the face LOL but then I will go to jail I I'm too good of person to do something like that.

But I just want him to know that he's not going to get over on me and rip me off that money because that was my whole paycheck and now I am broke I live paycheck to paycheck and I was getting ahead when I was driving that car because of gas mileage and he really screwed my whole summer and my whole life this summer up he doesn't even know.

Yes I am very upset I will send pictures of the receipt and the parts that are in the back of my car and the parts that he supposedly installed when I get a chance but that's the outcome of that whole thing.

Hope you are having a great weekend! I am definitely going to try to enjoy mine. I just charged up the battery on my car and going to try to drive it to my house which is about 20 minutes away but I don't know if it will do that or not it's got a brand new battery so I'm thinking it should be enough to get me home at least so I can take the alternator out here and get a new one
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, September 6th, 2025 AT 12:37 PM
Tiny
KEN L
  • MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
  • 54,137 POSTS
Wow, I am really bummed out this garage did this to you but it happens. Like they say back to the drawing board. At least you have s good handle on what is wrong and what to look for in a good garage. Sorry again for you experience in car repair garages, dot go back and don't recommend anyone go there.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, September 6th, 2025 AT 4:20 PM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Nope everyone I know is pretty furious about it as well. Yeh all I van do is spread the word snd word gets around in these smaller midwest towns fast. Thanks for everything again. And as for the brake bleed. I am just going to put a couple of t's in and bypass the whole ABS block. So it will be just like old cars with their brakes with no ABS which I don't mind anyway or do you think that would work or not
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, September 7th, 2025 AT 10:00 AM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 34,330 POSTS
I've been following the "progress", but I still am waiting to see that someone gave a shot of compressed air into a non-flowing bleeder screw to reset the master cylinder. This is a five-second procedure that has bailed me out of dozens of vehicles that won't bleed out of two opposite wheels, one front and the opposite rear.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, September 7th, 2025 AT 4:37 PM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
No I have not tried that yet with the air at all I guess I'm not really sure what you're talking about or where you're shooting the air into I don't want to mess anything else up because it seems like everything I read and see on the internet I try to do it and ended up breaking more stuff because I don't know the correct way of doing it and they make it look easy on videos
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, September 7th, 2025 AT 7:20 PM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Here's a picture of all the month new parts that the mechanic was supposed to install and never did
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, September 7th, 2025 AT 7:20 PM
Tiny
KEN L
  • MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
  • 54,137 POSTS
Yep, those look like good parts, did you want to try installing them yourself? We can help walk you thought it, CARADIODOC and myself ;)
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, September 8th, 2025 AT 11:02 AM
Tiny
JEEP769
  • MEMBER
  • 47 POSTS
Cardio are you talking about shooting fresh air through the non bleeding screw in the caliper or what or through the master cylinder somehow I don't understand and could I just bypass the ABS block I did ask it question but no answer didn't know if anyone really knew or not
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, September 8th, 2025 AT 5:27 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 34,330 POSTS
Absolutely. Way back, I mentioned this but probably didn't go into enough detail. Everything discussed so far suggests the master cylinder is a common design from GM. Imagine a teeter totter inside that stays balanced, or "neutral". Brake fluid is free to flow out of both ports when the pedal is pressed. One port feeds fluid to the left front and right rear brakes. The other port feeds fluid to the other two wheels.

As long as the same brake fluid pressure builds up in each half of the system, that teeter totter stays balanced. It's when they develop different pressures, or more accurately, different flow volumes, that the teeter totter is pulled off-center, then a valve tip blocks that port. The purpose of this is when you spring a leak, such as from a ruptured rubber flex hose or a rusted metal line, fluid flow to the leak is blocked so you don't pump all the brake fluid out onto the ground. I described previously how the steering and suspension geometry was redesigned to counteract a very hard steering wheel pull when this occurs, so the only clue you have is the red "Brake" warning light. Very often people don't even know they're driving on half their brakes, and they get confused when the pads wear out quickly on one front brake repeatedly, while those on the other side look like new.

I don't know if you can trip this valve by bench-bleeding the new master cylinder. You aren't building any pressure, and both sides flow the same volume. Besides a customer coming in with a leak, this valve commonly trips during pedal-bleeding with a helper. Standard practice is to open just one bleeder screw at a time. That's the same as having a leak. No pressure can build up when the bleeder screw is open. In the other half of the system, pressure does build when the pedal is pressed. THAT is what trips the valve. Too often that tripped valve is misinterpreted as a defective master cylinder, when in fact, it did exactly what it was designed to do. Replacing the master cylinder over and over isn't going to help until you let one of them gravity-bleed without pressing the brake pedal. I think you can get away with pushing the pedal less than halfway to the floor, but we tend to push it too far.

As long as brake fluid flows from two wheels, you might as well finish those up and get the air out, then, the only way I have found to unseat that valve is to give that short, quick shot of compressed air into the open bleeder screw of one of the brakes that is not flowing any fluid. You don't need to force that air all the way up to the master cylinder. That just makes it that much harder to bleed it back out. You also want to avoid pushing air into the anti-lock brake hydraulic controller. Many of them require a scanner to bleed the air out of them. Rather, I use a rubber-tipped air nozzle, and I give it a quick karate chop to the handle. I suspect the air goes in less than a foot up the line because it's all bled out again very quickly. The cap on the brake fluid reservoir should be loose so no pressure builds up there that would fight what you're trying to do.

A lot of experienced professionals will tell you this valve won't trip if you bleed the four brakes in a specific order, usually starting with the right rear, but logic dictates that is not true. Even some service manuals say the same thing, but if you think about it, if that valve doesn't trip when you bleed the right rear first, it won't trip if you develop a leak in that circuit either, so there's no point in having that feature. I always start bleeding with the wheel I'm standing closest to.

Another trick when you do have to replace the master cylinder, is to loosen the two soft metal line nuts a little, then unbolt the master cylinder from the power booster, pull it forward off the mounting studs, use it as a handle to bend the steel lines up a little, then finish unbolting the lines. Bending the lines prevents a little brake fluid from running out. Bench-bleed the new master cylinder, connect it to the lines, bend the lines back down, and bolt the unit in place. You'll need a helper for this next step. Snug one line nut. Leave the other one a little loose. Have your helper push the brake pedal very slowly so it takes roughly 15 seconds to go halfway to the floor. You'll see air bubbles coming out at the loose nut. Be sure to snug that nut first, THEN holler to the helper to release the pedal quickly. Open that nut and do the same thing, and maybe once more, until no air bubbles come out. Next, do the same thing with the other line.

By pushing slowly on the pedal, what little air might be in the line floats back up as brake fluid goes down. By releasing the pedal quickly, the brake fluid rushing back up into the reservoir washes any air bubbles back up with it. In this way, you don't have to bleed at the wheels and there's no chance of getting air trapped in the ABS hydraulic controller. Even if a few tiny air bubbles are still trapped, you'll never know it, and they will eventually flow into the reservoir. Air doesn't float down.

Please come back and tell us this worked.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Monday, September 8th, 2025 AT 5:57 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.