Second gear if I try to accelerate will throw the shift out and right in neutral

ZACH.WATTS

MEMBER
1998 AUDI A4
1.8L
4 CYL
TURBO
4WD
MANUAL
250,000 MILES

My check engine light came on then the next day I was driving around running errands and as I was almost home second gear popped out. Every gear is still there and the car drives. I put it in second and let the clutch out and it will hold second gear but if I put power into it it will throw the shift out and right in neutral. Is it just the clutch or do I need to pull the transmission apart and replace second gear?

1 Reply

JOETECHPRO

MECHANIC
705 POSTS

Hey ZACH. WATTS,

I would say before pulling the transmission apart you will need to check the engine and transmission mounts and also the condition of the shift linkage.

Is there a lot of play in the shifter, does the shifter feel loose?
If you can access the shift linkage from underneath the car check the bushings for play and wear.

Also checking the transmission for leaks and ensuring proper fluid level.

If the clutch is released and you are just accelerating in second when this happens this will rule out the clutch being the problem.

Any further questions don't hesitate to ask.

Regards, Joe