Go to a auto parts store like autozone have them read the codes and let me know what they are and ill help u out. Let me know.
April, 8, 2010 AT 8:45 AM
Hello, I had to take my car to a Pep Boys, they ran a free diagnostic. They said I needed to take it to a transmission shop cuz the code 02 sensor said " gear ratio for #1 is incorrect".
I called the transmission shop they recommended and they also have a free diagnostic. And they said if they end up taking apart the transmission, then it will cost me about $475, and labor is a part of that.
April, 8, 2010 AT 11:38 AM
If u have that code for first gear it should be code p0731 the good news is if u had a bad piston for first gear u would have to take the transmission out or completely apart to service it. All u have to do is to remove ur side cover on the transmission ur first gear clutch pack is at the end of ur input shaft under ur side cover out side the transmission. My guess is u have a loose input shaft nut pretty common on the newer s model saturns that would require removing the side cover and replacing the nut. If the nut gets too loose I have seen the side cover get damaged and from the nut being to loose and it sliding from side to side warp and bend the second gear clutch plates causing the car to to move foward in neautral and other shifting problems.U will just have to let them look at it before it becomes a bigger problem. But make sure they check the first gear actuator and the first gear piston. Let them know what I told u about ur car. Let me know what they say before they make a repair and I'll let u know what questions to ask them. Let me know what they find.
April, 8, 2010 AT 11:52 AM
Welll, what I did was research a bit on the transmission shop. I found out that they do some shabby work, been taken to court, etc, have an F- rating on BBB. So I reseached another place closer to me called Mr Transmission and they have an A- rating, etc. They also said that if they had to take apart the transmission, that is it not $497, but $395 and I do have a $100 coupon too. They actually went to Pep boys and picked up the car for free and took it to their place to take care of it for me since I could not get it myself there till later. But when they call, I will see what they say. And I will read to them what you said. But as far as sending you the reply and waiting for your reply back, I don't think I can hold on for that long. But I will play it by ear for now, and will let you know everything they say. I am writing down everything.
April, 8, 2010 AT 12:24 PM
Well if they say they have to take the transmission out and all the way apart then something is wrong unless there is a damaged input shaft or something like that. Also have them check the trans line pressure with the line pressure fuse in and out and get the readings for both and let me know what they are. Low line pressure in the transmission will cause this code as well as the loose nut. They have problems with the pressure regulator in valve body usually causes codes like p0733 and p0734 which is gears 3rd and fourth. Let me know I have worked on these transmissions for over 16yrs and Iam factory trained on them.I did the trip to spring hill Tennessee for three weeks where there made and was factory trained by Saturn. So let me know.
April, 8, 2010 AT 12:53 PM
Hello, I just got done talking to them. They saidit was a valve body & accumulator, they said I was really kind of like missing 1st gear and I don't have a stick shift. It is going to cost total, $913.51. They cannot get a remanufactured one on it.
Is there a number I can reach you at or can u just answer this asap.
April, 8, 2010 AT 2:27 PM
Well the labor hrs on replacing the valve body not including diagnoses is 2.3hrs for non abs and if u have abs its 2.6hrs times whatever the labor rate is. The valve body from the dealer is 725.00 so depending on his labor rate that sounds right for replacing the valve body did he say how he diagnosed it as a valve body issue?Did he remove the valve body and air check the clutches including first gear?What that entails is taking air and forcing it into all the transmission clutch feed holes then let the air sit in there with no new air supply and seeing if the piston clutchs bleed the air down or if the air comes out another feed hole meaning theres cross bleeding. If he didnt do that u could have another problem like a loose input shaft nut or a leaking piston. Did he even perform a line pressure test with and without the line pressure fuse in?Usually if u get a bad valve body u will get a delay in reverse or bang in reverse and sometimes a p0733 and a p0734 no 3rd and no 4th gear or incorrect ratio. Because the higher gears need more pressure to hold the clutch packs from slipping. But ask him how he figured out it needs a valve body. And what the line pressure was at with the line pressure fuse in and with it out. From these questions u will catch him off gaurd and u will be able to tell if he knows what he is talking about. They also sell rebulit and worked valve bodys for a few hundred dollars. Let me know what he says.
April, 8, 2010 AT 2:38 PM
Hi, he said that he did many diagnostics and it all pointed to the valve body & accumulator. He said I could get the remanufactured one, but they would not warranty it and it would cost a couple of hundred less. I have told him what you have said and he thinks you are funny. That he has been in the business over 20 yrs and that he knows what he is doing. By the way, I did call AAMCO and told them my dilemma and he said that the price I got quoted was reasonable, it was about that much with them. I will be hones, I have no idea if I am being taken advantage of, but I am having FAITH on this that I am not. I have no idea what else they did to determine what I had to have done, but I guess obviously I don't know what they are doing or suppose to do, and both you and he does.
April, 8, 2010 AT 2:41 PM
By the way, I am not sure of this, but if you are referring to the clutch as in a stick shift, I don't have a stick, I have an automatic.
April, 8, 2010 AT 3:19 PM
Yeah I know that u have a automatic transmission its basicialy a manual trans with planetary gears with clutch pistions that are filled with fluid and pressure to in engage them instead of being shifted into manually with shift forks.A very simple good design. He thinks iam funny when iam asked to explain how I came to a diagnose on a customers transmission I dont say I performed many diagnostics and it all pointed to x or y I tell what I did to find out what was wrong. He could very well be in the bussiness for 20 yrs in transmissions but I specialized in saturns working at the dealers I have even been shop foremans and team leaders there for over 16yrs I have saturn certs they gave me to prove it. To me my opion the way he answered ur question by how he performed many diagnostics and wouldnt answer a simple question like what ur transmission pressure was if he air checked ur clutches etc then says iam funny sounds like he is the clown thats just my opion. Doing the steps I have told u is basic steps to determine if u have a bad valve body or a leaking pistion bad seal loose input shaft nut etc.U can belive who u want iam not there to see or do any testing thats why I asked u to ask him those questions. Sounds like he didnt like my questions thats why he got all defense of with iam funny and his 20 yrs expernice. Jsut make sure he will stand behind his work like if ur service light comes back on with ur p0731 first gear incorrect ratio he isnt going to charge u a bunch more money and say its a differnt problem.A quick story I dont drop names so I will in directly drop one. That other place u called to see if it was a fair price they brought in a car into the dealer I worked at with a transmission problem that they rebuilt the whole transmission everything clutches seals everything for a hard shift in every gear. This was a customers of theres I looked at the car for like 20 mins called them back to tell them it was just a bad line pressure actuator a in car repair.I dont know if they ate the mistake or the customer on that one. And there comercial says no body knows ur transmission like us. And I have nothing to gain or loose in this one iam just here to answer questions which I volunteer my own free time to do so. So on this one I gave u my opion and u can do with it what u wish but keep me posted I would love to hear what happens with ur car. Also remember iam here if u have anymore questions.