Truck sways left/right

Tiny
REDKEASH
  • MEMBER
  • 2005 FORD EXPEDITION
  • 2.1L
  • V8
  • 4WD
  • AUTOMATIC
  • 167,000 MILES
I had my tie rod ends and one ball joint replace.

The control arm does not look like it was put back in the correct spot as I can visually tell by the appearance (cleaner looking).

My truck goes left than to the right when I got a bump.

My alignment is perfect!

My tires are perfect!

My toe rod inner and outer are new.

None of this happened until after toe rod ends and right front ball joint was replaced.

I hope this makes sense and appreciate any feedback. I went to three shops and all are telling me different "could be" scenarios. However, I strongly believe it was something put back wrong because issue did occur until after replacements to pass inspection.

I am a female and they just keep throwing me around, no offense guys. I have paid for alignments twice and brought tires twice. Please help me. I just want to fix the actual problem. I have a appointment at Ford on Tuesday.
Thursday, October 12th, 2017 AT 10:04 AM

6 Replies

Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,763 POSTS
Did you get a printout of the alignment? If you have that, post the numbers for front "caster", "camber", and "total toe". There should also be numbers for left and right "steering axis inclination, (SAI).

As for a part installed in the wrong location, control arms and ball joints hold the wheels in alignment. If the alignment really is correct, the parts holding the wheels have to be correct.

When you say "the alignment is perfect", how are you defining "perfect"? I scrutinize the numbers on the alignment computer, and "read" the tire wear patterns, as well as observing the vehicle's behavior on a test-drive. You are describing symptoms that suggest the alignment is not perfect.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, October 12th, 2017 AT 6:40 PM
Tiny
REDKEASH
  • MEMBER
  • 4 POSTS
Really! I took it to two different places and the last place was a collision shop. I am so confused. I did not get a printout but he was showing me on the machine that all was dead center in the green. I guess I should of got printout cause today I got it measured again and the alignment was off by a amount he felt was significant. I should of wrote it down. I am too scared to drive it because it is like it has its own mind. I broke down and towed it to a shop that will cost me an arm and leg probably. :(
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, October 12th, 2017 AT 6:57 PM
Tiny
REDKEASH
  • MEMBER
  • 4 POSTS
By the vwaybits a continuous left to right until it corrects itself. Is it possible the new tie rods I brought were bad? What can cause a alignment to jump off that bad for swaying as soon as they take it off the alignment rack?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, October 12th, 2017 AT 7:04 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,763 POSTS
What you are describing is a real common problem on GM front-wheel-drive cars after the engine or transmission were removed. It has to do with reinstalling the frame cross member. There is nothing, other than the mechanic's awareness of the potential problem, that insures that cross member will be properly centered. When it is not, it will change "camber" on the two front wheels by moving their bottoms to the left or to the right. While camber can be adjusted and made to look perfect, the underlying cause hasn't been addressed. That will cause the car to dart in various directions when hitting small bumps in the road. It will have no "predictability", meaning you have no idea which way it's going to go. This can't happen on Chrysler products because they have special bolts to force things to line up when put back together. On most Ford products the cross member is welded on and can't be removed or misadjusted, however, we still need to look for signs of something that is not equal on both sides. That is "steering axis inclination", (SAI). There is no spec given for that. All that is critical is it is the same on both sides. A typical value might be, oh, 28 degrees. You want the two readings to be within 0.2 degrees of each other.

The next thing is camber is the wheel leaning in or out on top, as viewed from in front of the vehicle. Ford has used some settings on their cars that are extremely horrendous for tire wear, as in 15,000 miles max per set, but they ride real nice. You could easily see those tires leaning over. This is not as much of a problem on their bigger vehicles, but it is one of the tricks they pull to sell more vehicles. Besides affecting tire wear, camber has the biggest effect on pulling to one side when you let go of the steering wheel. The two settings need to be the same to offset each other, then we make the left wheel just a little higher to create a slight pull to the left to offset "road crown". That is the roads slanting to the right so rain runs off.

"Caster" is a lot harder to explain, and you cannot see it, but it has about half the affect on pulling as does camber. Caster is what makes the steering wheel return to center on ts own after you make a turn. It also creates stability, or the tendency for the vehicle to not wander back and forth across the road. Instead of making camber slightly higher on the left to offset road crown, we can make caster slightly higher on the right wheel to do the same thing. Either one is perfectly acceptable. Where the problem comes in is you could have a 0.5 degree camber pull to the left, and if it is not possible to correct hat, you can adjust in 1.0 degrees pull to the right with caster to offset it. In theory the vehicle would go straight, but only when road forces are equal on both tires. That rarely happens in actual driving. In fact, the numbers on the alignment computer are only accurate for a vehicle that is standing still, not one in motion when the geometry of the suspension parts are going through their range of motions.

Camber affects how the tires tug on the road, and that changes as the road surfaces lean more or less. That is always changing as you drive. Caster makes a wheel want to flop in toward the center of the vehicle. With the steering linkage connecting the two sides, if both caster settings are equal, they'll offset each other and the car will go straight. The vehicle will dart to one side to follow the front tire with the least weight on it, and that too is constantly changing as you drive over even tiny bumps and ripples on the road surface. Also, too much caster can lead to what we call the "death wobble". The steering system wants to come back to centered, and comes back so fast, it overshoots and goes the other way. Road forces keep that going, like a grandfather clock pendulum, until you slow down. You'll never want to go through that again!

The point of all this is going back to my comment about unequal camber being offset with unequal caster, if those differences are bad enough, it can lead to any combination of the symptoms I described. This is the short version of what it took me eight weeks to teach.

One more thing you might consider is most trucks use a steering stabilizer, which is essentially, just a special shock absorber, connected to the steering linkage. When adjusting the alignment, or when replacing certain other parts, that stabilizer can end up slightly extended or retracted relative to where it was before. That is perfectly acceptable and normal, and has no effect on its operation, until it develops an internal worn spot. That can reduce its effectiveness when it's in that one orientation, and now that might be when the steering wheel is perfectly straight. It could fail to do its job when you are driving straight ahead. On many trucks that stabilizer ends up being bolted back on in a different orientation if we have to remove it for other services, and that rarely causes a problem. This is one of those things we have to think about when looking for the elusive cause of a problem.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Thursday, October 12th, 2017 AT 9:02 PM
Tiny
REDKEASH
  • MEMBER
  • 4 POSTS
This is crazy! It is fixed now! The original mechanic put the tie d on passenger side backwards!
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, October 13th, 2017 AT 10:59 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,763 POSTS
That is not possible any more than you can put your shoe on backward. I suspect there was some other mistake that would have been much more difficult to explain. Mechanics already have very poor communication skills when working with car owners, and we tend to find simple explanations that we hope you will understand.

What I CAN envision happening is tie rod ends have to be able to swivel as the wheel bounces up and down, and as the wheel turns through its range of motions. Some of the more common designs can be set so the inner tie rod end can only swivel just so far, and to swivel the other way, the outer tie rod end is already at the end it its range of travel. That technically is not an installation error. It is a mistake made by the alignment specialist. There's a threaded link that is rotated to adjust the length of the two tie rod end assembly to set the direction the wheel is steering when the steering wheel is straight. What commonly happens when there is one new, snug tie rod end, and the other one is old and a little sloppy, turning the adjuster sleeve tugs on and turns the sloppy joint with it, but the tight one doesn't get turned. Whichever way the assembly wants to swivel, one of the tie rod ends is already at the end of its travel. If it needs to rotate a little further, it can't so it binds and resists the action of whatever is trying to move it. You could feel that as the steering wheel gets tighter and tighter as you turn it more and more in one direction. You could feel it as the steering system gets pushed back toward center when one front tire hits a tiny bump.

The proper procedure when completing the alignment is to grab those linkages and just try to twist them. If it can be rotated by hand a sufficient amount, you're done. That test takes the better part of two seconds. If the linkage can't be rotated, it's a simple matter of treaking the adjustment of that link. This is a real common occurrence and is of no significance when it is handled right there on the alignment rack. The problem is it is real hard to identify this when it causes a problem later because you can't see the problem by just looking at the parts. You have to grab them and twist them. We grab them and try to move the ball and socket to see if there's excessive wear between them, but that doesn't show when they can't swivel.

Trying to explain this is WAY more involved than correcting it. If this is what really happened, my hat is off to the person who found it.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, October 14th, 2017 AT 11:29 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links