Bad Oil Change - Thrown Rod, Court Date 4/18, please reply.

Tiny
CARMENFLORA
  • MEMBER
  • 1918 HONDA CIVIC
Hello,

1990 Honda Civic, approx 150K miles. Manual Trans.

On November 15 I got an oil change at Sears Auto Center. I drove approximately 9 blocks and threw a rod. I checked the oil first thing and the stick was dry, nor was there any oil on the ground.

Sears sent (after an hour of waiting on the side of the road) a tech with nothing more than 4 quarts of oil with the hopes that they could add it and my car would start, so it could be driven back to the shop. By this time it was dark and raining. He did not have a flash light. Regardless, he was able to add 4 quarts to the pan. The car would not start anyway (thank goodness).

Finally, they called a tow truck and had my car towed back to the shop where they proceeded to put it on racks and drain out the full 4 quarts of oil that the tech added at the site of breakdown. They checked the seals and plug as well as the filter. My dad says that he heard the techs say that it was weird that the filter was dry?

Sears could not diagnose catastrophic enging failure so they had my car towed to Honda of Seattle.

The next day I get a call from Sears saying that I threw a rod and it was not related to the oil change. I said that I wanted to talk to the contact at honda so I could get the information direct.

When I got the tech at Honda on the phone I quickly realized that he had not been given all of the info. The Honda tech was not aware that no oil was ever an issue and was not told that the car had ever left their lot. As soon as he was made aware of this information he went back to the car and found that the oil filter did not have any oil in it, yet there was 4 quarts of oil in the pan?

They determined that there was most likley never any oil put back in the car.

Sears still denies claim since they could tell that there was recent enginge work done (replacement of a cracked head).

I have filed papers for small claims (court date April 18th) and am trying to find information that states that a thrown rod is caused by lack of, or no oil (I am aware that there can be other reasons too).

looking for a place I can find this info and any comments you might have on the issue.

Let it be known that I was lied to on many occassions (including the Manager of Operations stating that the car would not even start if there was no oil - I know that I am a girl, but am aware that is FALSE)

Thanks kindly!
Andrea
Monday, April 9th, 2007 AT 1:09 PM

2 Replies

Tiny
BRUCE HUNT
  • MECHANIC
  • 3,753 POSTS
I would simply get a sworn statement from the mechanic at Honda telling of the dry oil filter and that since it was dry after any starting of the engine, along with a statement from the towing company to verify that you were away from the Sears store, the service representative at Sears failed to put any oil in after the draining and installation of the filter. They are wrong, very wrong, but mistakes are made. You want restitution and you want to be treated fairly. You have expected fair treatment. Common sense, maybe again a statement by the service technician at Honda that cars are required to have oil to continue to run, not to start, but to enable the engine to remain cool and lubricated. Without the oil, engine damage is imminent.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, April 9th, 2007 AT 3:51 PM
Tiny
CARMENFLORA
  • MEMBER
  • 5 POSTS
I WON! The judge even awarded me the 4000 that I asked for which is 3 times the Blue Book value. Because of the evidence and the fact that they refused to work with me, I got it all!
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+2
Wednesday, April 18th, 2007 AT 9:21 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links