2CarPros - Car Questions & Answers

1999 BMW 316 Repair Question


Topics covered: Mechanic, Noise, Dent.
Mileage: No information provided.

Asked on August 31, 2008

1999 BMW 316 Whistling Noise on rundown and at idle


Hi.... I am experiencing a high pitched whistle in my 99 E46 BMW 316i 1.9. It happens once the car warms up after 20 miles or so.... It disappears if you fully press the accelerator but is louder as the car comes down to idle speed. Already changed the idle regulator at the advice of a shoddy mechanic who lied to me that he had fixed the problem. Please please please help... this noise is ruining my life... my vin is aw52308
Avatar Asked by stevenmac

Answer

Replied on August 31, 2008

Your life is not being ruined, all is well. Please repost with the vehicle identification number so that I know how to advise you.

Tiny Answered by Dr. Hagerty (expert)
9,669 answers provided
Replied on July 28, 2012

hello, i am also experiencing the exact problem with my BMW 316. I have gone to three or four mechanics and everyone has diagnosed different problem. Kindly tell me how have u rectified it and what was the exact cause. Thanks

Tiny Answered by hussain54
0 questions asked
Replied on October 26, 2012

11157501567 is the part you need, it is the crankcase vent valve

Tiny Answered by Dr. Hagerty (expert)
9,669 answers provided