2004 Renault Megane • 101,000 miles

Hi, I took my car for an MOT in 2011 and was told the steering rack had gone. Fair enough I paid £765 for it to be replaced. I took it back to the same garage in 2012 for the MOT and was told the steering rack had gone. I said that seemed strange as they had fit a new one 11 months previously. They said the part must have been faulty but was under warranty and fit it for me free. There has been a knocking sound when I turn the steering wheel and I knew the steering rack had gone again. I took it back to the same garage and the part is under warranty but they are trying to charge me £140 for labour. They are asking whether I go over bumpy roads. I literally use the car to go to work and back (a 10-15 minute drive on main roads). I need some advice as I feel like I am being conned. This will be the third time they fit a new steering rack. Are they not fitting it properly or is there another reason for this part failing? The garage are denying it is their fault and I don't see why I should have to pay for their labour when I paid for the part and for them to fit it in 2011! Please help!
February 18, 2013.

Check out the related content below while we wait for the question to be answered by a professional mechanic.