Logo Automobile Information Add Site to Favorites  
Auto Repair
Auto Repair Home
Auto Repair Ask a Car Repair Question
Auto Repair Car Repair Question Archive
Auto Repair Repair Troubleshooting
Auto Repair How to Repair or Service
Auto Repair Car Repair Forum
Auto Repair Auto Repair Manuals
Auto Repair How to use Diagnostic Tools
Auto Repair Auto Term Abbreviations
Auto Repair Brake Replacement Guides
Auto Repair Service Engine Soon Light
 
Popular Site Links

  

Auto Repair Maintenance Schedule
Auto Repair How Does it Work?
Auto Repair Car Repair Video Series
Auto Repair Car Safety Inspection
Auto Repair Timing Belt Marks
Auto Repair Drive Belt Routing Diagrams
Auto Repair Trouble Code Table
Auto Repair Avoid Car Repair Rip Offs
Auto Repair Smog Test Preparation
Auto Repair Car Replacement Parts
Auto Repair Test Equipment Store
 
Search Website
 
 
Recent Repair Topics

 

Auto Repair1999 Gmc C1500 Losing C...
Auto Repair1998 Ford Escort Locati...
Auto Repair2002 Chevy Malibu Blink...
Auto Repair1998 Chevy Truck No Bra...
Auto Repair1998 Ford Escort Car Br...
Auto Repair2004 Ford F250 Back-up ...
Auto Repair1995 Jaguar Xj6 Car Sta...
Auto Repair More Repair Topics...
 
Site Advertising
     
 

Car Repair Chat - Ask a Question, Get a FREE Answer.

Log inLog in RegisterRegister ProfileProfile Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages SearchSearchFAQFAQ



 Go Back

2005 Volkswagen Jetta glow plug



Welcome to our question and answer forum. We answer over 6,000 free and donated auto repair questions every month. All you have to do to ask a question is to signup to our forum.

Asking a question is free of charge and your question will be answered by one of our non-certified forum users for free. You can however elect to donate to make sure your question gets an guaranteed and professional answer by one of our many 2carpros certified repair technicians.

Questions with donations are answered as promptly as possible. Due to the nature of car repair problems, some take longer to solve than others. We are confident that you will be better informed regarding your problem and will have an good idea of what direction your repair needs to go after we have answered it. If you have donated and were unsatisfied with our effort we will gladly return your donation. We help thousands of people every month and want to help you too. Sometimes it requires some dialog between our technicians and you to get to the bottom of your problem. 100% of the donation is awarded to the technicians helping you.

New Watch our new Car Repair Video Series with Ken Lavacot.


Posted at Fri Jun 06, 2008 6:07 pm
By smcq, Have Donated
Give Feedback | Votes: 0
   
Engine Mechanical problem
2005 Volkswagen Jetta Front Wheel Drive Manual 70,000 miles
----------------------------------------------------------------
I've got a TDI

anyhow, the glow plug was being replaced by my normally wonderful mechanic. The glow plug broke when he was removing it and it fell into the diesel engine. So I had to pay for the cylinder head to be removed to retrieve the piece.

Plus, I just had a 70,000 tune-up 3 weeks ago and because of this new problem the oil and everything was changed again. Is it my responsibility to pay for all that?
thank you!
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote
Posted at Fri Jun 06, 2008 6:07 pm
By Advertisment,
   
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Posted at Fri Jun 06, 2008 9:50 pm
By Dr. Hagerty, Moderator
Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3 (375) Give Feedback | Votes: 8
   
In a word, No, I would not have discarded the oil nor would I have charged a customer for my lack of skill at removing something that I put there.
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote
Posted at Sat Jun 07, 2008 6:05 am
By smcq, Have Donated
Give Feedback | Votes: 0
   
Well, he didn't put it there - it's been there since I bought the car new.

With also replacing the shocks (which is the reason I took it in to begin with and also that my glow plug light had come on), the total bill was over $1200.

I'm not sure why I didn't dissect the costs when he charged me. I think I had sticker shock, plus, I've always trusted him and assumed he wouldn't charge me if not necessary. But I'm thinking of protesting the $500+ labor charge for the engine.

Opinion please...
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote
Posted at Sat Jun 07, 2008 7:00 am
By Dr. Hagerty, Moderator
Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3Reputation: 375.3 (375) Give Feedback | Votes: 8
   
It is curious how the story changes isn't it?
anyhow, the glow plug was being replaced by my normally wonderful mechanic. The glow plug broke when he was removing it and it fell into the diesel engine. So I had to pay for the cylinder head to be removed to retrieve the piece.
Then,
Well, he didn't put it there - it's been there since I bought the car new.
So where is the truth?
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote
Posted at Sun Jun 08, 2008 7:06 am
By smcq, Have Donated
Give Feedback | Votes: 0
   
I bought the car new in 2005. Recently the glow plug had to be replaced. He went to pull it out and it broke off into the engine. I had to pay.

thanks for your correspondance about this....
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote
Posted at Sat Jul 05, 2008 10:40 pm
By KHLow2008, Moderator
Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6Reputation: 215.6 (216) Give Feedback | Votes: 12
   
Hi smcq,

It is an accidental type of problem whereby the plug was faulty and while removing it broke, so the fault does not entirely fall on the mechanic unless it could be proven that he damaged it through improper removal.

The owner should be directly responsible for the repairs but as a gesture of good will, the mechanic could have given a reduced price on labor for the repairs.
 
Find diagnostic tools, replacement parts or locate a car repair manual for your Volkswagen Jetta Repair Question.
 
Reply with quote

Reply to topic
 

Make a small donation! (We will make sure your question will be answered promptly)

 
 
 
Go Back
Forum Home
 
 

 


 
Find a repair manual for your car - Get instant access to your vehicles drive belt routing, wiring diagrams, trouble code information and other available updates and factory bulletins. Click here to find out more.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Popular Service Repairs
Test Fuses
Front Brake Pads
Tune Up
Transmission Service
Rear Brake Pads
Rear Brake Shoes
Replace Window Motor
Test Alternator
Test Battery

Replace Air Filter

Check Engine Light

More Service Repairs...
Advertisement

Car Repair Home l Help l Privacy Policy l User Agreement l About Us l Contact Us l Link to Us l Affiliate Program
  Copyright © 1998 - 2008 2CarPros.com - Professional Mechanics Online